Introduction
To help you book the best hotel in New York that fits your needs, travel style, and budget, we have already done the research for you.
For each destination, we spend hours categorizing and filtering hotels to each specific area and budget tier, reading and analyzing the reviews in detail, and comparing the reviews between qualifying hotels.
We specifically also study the negative reviews. It is important to determine whether it was a once-off bad experience of one guest or whether it is a recurring problem also mentioned in other reviews.
We also evaluate the enthusiasm with which reviews were written. You could have two hotels, both with a 9.3 guest rating, but most of the reviews of the one might be along the lines of “It was good”, whereas most of the reviews of the other might be explaining how wonderful it was, how it was the best hotel experience they have ever had and why they would return to this hotel or why they are already on a repeat visit. Both hotels have 9.3, but surely the enthusiastic 9.3 should weigh heavier.
Last but not least, we consider the convenience of the location, the amenities provided, the proximity to public transport, and the value for money offered.
Only after this lengthy process, our selection is made.
Making it Easy for You to Choose
We have selected four geographical areas, each with its own character and benefits, making it easy for you to choose the area where you want to stay. In each area, we have selected one hotel in each of four budget tiers, to easily allow you to make a choice according to your specific travel style and budget. Hotels were only selected after careful consideration, as explained above, from qualifying hotels holding a guest rating of 9/10 or higher as at time of writing.
About the Guest Ratings
Trip.com guest ratings (as at time of writing and updated periodically) are quoted for each hotel selected, but for a hotel to have been considered for selection, it should have had a guest rating of 9/10 or higher on both Trip.com and Expedia and it should have demonstrated broadly positive review trends across other major booking platforms. Guest ratings change from time to time and might, therefore, be different from the one quoted, at the time you do your booking.
The Four Budget Tiers
- Economy (under US$500 per night): Reliable hotels offering comfort, excellent location and exceptional value for money.
- Premium Economy (US$500-US$900 per night): Quality hotels providing a step up in comfort and design with better amenities.
- Business Class (US$900-US$1500 per night): Full-service hotels perfect for both leisure and business travelers seeking high-end facilities, stylish interiors, and premium service.
- First Class (above US$1500 per night): World-class luxury with signature addresses at premium locations and with exceptional amenities.
While the tiers above remain the same for each destination, the nightly price ranges for each tier may differ from destination to destination. The price ranges above are for this destination specifically and were valid at the time of writing. Due to the fact that hotel rates fluctuate constantly depending on factors such as season, demand, and promotions, the price ranges might be different or a specific hotel might have moved outside the price range at the time when you do your booking. The budget tiers and price ranges are, therefore, to be used as a general guide to provide an overall sense of value and positioning.
The Four Geographical Areas
- Brooklyn (Williamsburg / DUMBO / Brooklyn Heights) – Creative, Trendy, Waterfront, Skyline Views, Local Atmosphere
- Midtown Manhattan (Times Square / Empire State Building / Fifth Avenue) – Central Location, Iconic Landmarks, Entertainment, Shopping, Excellent Transport
- Lower Manhattan (SoHo / Tribeca / Greenwich Village / Chelsea) – Boutique Feel, Dining Scene, Historic Streets, Culture, Walkable
- Upper Manhattan (Central Park / Upper East Side / Upper West Side) – Central Park, Museums, Residential, Calm, Classic New York
1. Brooklyn (Williamsburg / DUMBO / Brooklyn Heights)
Brooklyn, offering a different perspective on the city compared to Manhattan, has a more relaxed atmosphere. It is still putting you close to the action with excellent transport links to Manhattan and having some of the best skyline views in the city.
Economy: Ace Hotel Brooklyn
Check price on Trip.com Check price on Expedia
Trip.com Guest Rating: 9.4/10
Location:
- 252 Schermerhorn St, Brooklyn, New York, New York State, 11217, United States
- 120m from Hoyt-Schermerhorn Streets Metro Station
- 470m from DeKalb Avenue Metro Station
- 3.8 km from Brooklyn Cruise Terminal
- 4.7 km from Wall Street
Hotel Highlights:
- Centrally located in Brooklyn
- Easy access to subway lines, trendy restaurants, and cultural venues
- Fitness Centre
- 5-Minute drive to Barclays Centre Brooklyn and Prospect Park
- Dog-friendly
What Guests Loved:
- Very courteous staff
- Gym with great equipment
- Large room, excellent amenities, and comfortable bed
- Excellent location and subway station just across the street
- Clean, comfortable, and spacious rooms
Premium Economy
No Premium Economy hotel in this area currently meets our rating standard to be considered for inclusion in this guide.
Business Class: 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge
Check price on Trip.com Check price on Expedia
Trip.com Guest Rating: 9.0/10
Location:
- 60 Furman St, Brooklyn, New York, New York State, 11201, United States
- 720m from High Street – Brooklyn Bridge Metro Station
- 850m from York Street Metro Station
- 3 km from Atlantic Train Terminal
- 29.9 km from John F. Kennedy International Airport
Hotel Highlights:
- Located on the riverwalk, 5 minutes by foot from Brooklyn Bridge
- Outdoor pool, spa, massage room, and gym
- Public parking, valet parking, EV charging station, and shuttle service
- Childcare service
- English, Dutch, French, Italian, Spanish, Russian, and German spoken
What Guests Loved:
- Beautiful environment and room accommodations
- Well kept and clean, easy access to DUMBO and the rest of the city
- Excellent staff, clean room, fantastic onsite restaurants
- Absolutely breathtaking rooms
- Very clean, great service, beautiful views
First Class
No First Class hotel in this area currently meets our rating standard to be considered for inclusion in this guide.
2. Midtown Manhattan (Times Square / Empire State Building / Fifth Avenue)
If you are a first-time visitor to New York, this area might be the one you were imagining when planning your trip. With Times Square, the Empire State Building, and Fifth Avenue all in this area, it will also make sense to choose this area for your first trip to the city. You will be in the center of everything and this area will also make sense if your time to explore the city, is limited.
Economy: Casablanca Hotel by Library Hotel Collection
Check price on Trip.com Check price on Expedia
Trip.com Guest Rating: 9.3/10
Location:
- 147 W 43rd St, Manhattan, New York, New York State, 10036, United States
- 280m from Times Square Metro Station
- 300m from Bryant Park and 500m from 5th Avenue
- 370m from 42nd Street – Bryant Park Metro Station
- 1.1 km from Grand Central Terminal
Hotel Highlights:
- Steps from Broadway and Times Square
- Onsite self parking
- Pillowtop beds with down comforters and Egyptian cotton sheets
- Childcare service
- Multilingual in 10 languages
What Guests Loved:
- Immaculate, large, quiet, clean, and comfortable rooms
- Incredible and super friendly staff
- Beautiful hotel, great service, comfortable bed and a great location
- The lounge on the 2nd floor with fireplace, free coffee and 24-hour snack area
- Convenient nearby parking
Premium Economy: Hotel Giraffe by Library Hotel Collection
Check price on Trip.com Check price on Expedia
Trip.com Guest Rating: 9.6/10
Location:
- 365 Park Ave S, Manhattan, New York, New York State, 10016, United States
- 270m from 23rd Street Metro Station
- 960m from 14th Street – Union Square Metro Station
- 1 km from Empire State Building
- 1.8 km from Grand Central Terminal
Hotel Highlights:
- Steps from Madison Square Park and a 5-minute walk to 5th Avenue
- Limo/town car service
- Private and valet parking
- Pillowtop beds with down comforters and Egyptian cotton sheets
- Rooftop terrace with stunning views
What Guests Loved:
- Great value and nice continental breakfast
- 24-hour free coffee and snacks in lobby
- Spacious, comfortable and clean rooms
- Away from the crowd and noise, but very close to the heart of New York City
- Very friendly and helpful staff
Business Class: Pendry Manhattan West
Check price on Trip.com Check price on Expedia
Trip.com Guest Rating: 9.4/10
Location:
- Bar Pendry Level, 438 W 33rd St, Manhattan, New York, New York State, 10001
- 330m from New York Moynihan Train Hall at Penn Station
- 560m from 34th Street – Penn Metro Station
- 1 km from 34th Street – Herald Square Metro Station
- 3.1 km from Grand Central Terminal
Hotel Highlights:
- The Number 7 subway is located steps from the hotel
- Designed for the modern luxury traveller
- Bedding includes Fili d Oro luxury linen
- Fitness Centre
- Private and valet parking
What Guests Loved:
- Impeccable hospitality
- Excellent room, excellent service and good food quality
- Spacious and clean room with amazing views
- Amazing hotel with comfortable and quiet rooms close to Penn Station
- Amazing location
First Class: Mandarin Oriental New York
Check price on Trip.com Check price on Expedia
Trip.com Guest Rating: 9.4/10
Location:
- 80 Columbus Cir, Manhattan, New York, New York State, 10023, United States
- 100m from 59th Street – Columbus Circle Metro Station
- 680m from 57th Street – Seventh Avenue Metro Station
- 2.9 km from Grand Central Terminal
- 3.2 km from New York Moynihan Train Hall at Penn Station
Hotel Highlights:
- Outstanding service, luxurious accommodation, and prime location
- Breathtaking views of the Hudson River and Central Park
- Indoor pool, sauna, spa, massage room, and gym
- Private parking, valet parking and EV charging station
- Currency exchange and multilingual in 10 languages
What Guests Loved:
- Amazing suites, staff, and views
- Impeccable service
- Comfortable and spacious rooms with amazing views
- Excellent location right next to Central Park
- Beautiful rooms, great restaurant and bar with a view of Central Park
3. Lower Manhattan (SoHo / Tribeca / Greenwich Village / Chelsea)
With its historic streets, cast-iron buildings, and vibrant food scene, this area feels more intimate and residential than Midtown. If you enjoy walking, exploring smaller streets, and discovering independent restaurants and cafés, this area might be a good fit for you. This area is also favoured by repeat visitors to the city.
Economy: The Ludlow Hotel
Check price on Trip.com Check price on Expedia
Trip.com Guest Rating: 9.3/10
Location:
- 180 Ludlow St, Manhattan, New York, New York State, 10002, United States
- 350m from Second Avenue Metro Station
- 440m from Delancey Avenue Metro Station
- 2.8 km from Christopher Street Train Station
- 3.1 km from World Trace Centre Train Station
Hotel Highlights:
- Centrally located and within walking distance of New York University
- 24-hour Fitness centre
- Rooftop terrace with views
- Public parking
- Childcare service
What Guests Loved:
- Clean, comfortable, and cozy rooms
- Friendly and welcoming staff providing excellent service
- Fabulous atmosphere
- Delicious meals at hotel restaurant with several other restaurants nearby
- Great location and walking distance to SoHo
Premium Economy: NobleDEN Hotel
Check price on Trip.com Check price on Expedia
Trip.com Guest Rating: 9.3/10
Location:
- 196 Grand St, Manhattan, New York, New York State, 10013, United States
- 280m from Grand Street Metro Station
- 390m from Canal Street Metro Station
- 600m from Bowery Ballroom
- 1.8 km from World Trade Centre Train Station
Hotel Highlights:
- Steps from Italian American Museum and Mulberry Street
- Rooftop terrace with stunning views
- Near New York University
- Great location to explore the area
What Guests Loved:
- Phenomenal location with lots of good restaurants and shops nearby
- Clean room, comfortable bed, pillows and sheets
- Free coffee and tea counter
- Very friendly staff providing great recommendations
- Amazing rooftop view and close to subways
Business Class: Casa Cipriani New York
Check price on Trip.com Check price on Expedia
Trip.com Guest Rating: 9.2/10
Location:
- 10 South Street, Manhattan, New York, New York State, 10004, United States
- 170m from Whitehall Street – South Ferry Metro Station
- 190m from Court Street Metro Station
- 1.5 km from World Trade Centre Train Station
- 4.9 km from Christopher Street Train Station
Hotel Highlights:
- Located on the water in the iconic Battery Maritime Building
- Combining chic simplicity with maritime-inspired design themes
- Sauna, spa, massage room, and gym
- Childcare service
- Valet parking
What Guests Loved:
- Gorgeous water view from room
- The staff, the amenities, the food, the view, the room and the detail
- Mesmerizing views
- Amazing place and amazing service
- Incredible jazz room
First Class: Crosby Street Hotel
Check price on Trip.com Check price on Expedia
Trip.com Guest Rating: 9.5/10
Location:
- 79 Crosby Street, Manhattan, New York, New York State, 10012, United States
- 150m from Spring Street Metro Station
- 190m from Prince Street Metro Station
- 1.6 km from Christopher Street Train Station
- 2 km from World Trade Centre Train Station
Hotel Highlights:
- Situated on a quiet cobbled street in the heart of vibrant SoHo
- Multilingual
- Currency exchange
- Onsite public parking
- Fitness Centre with gym
What Guests Loved:
- In great area of SoHo – walking distance to restaurants, shops, and the subway
- Beautifully designed rooms
- Very clean and well located
- Friendly and helpful staff and excellent housekeeping
- An oasis in SoHo worth every penny
4. Upper Manhattan (Central Park / Upper East Side / Upper West Side)
If you prefer a more relaxed environment while still staying in Manhattan, this area might make sense to you. Centred around Central Park, it offers a calmer and more residential side of New York.
Economy: Hotel Beacon
Check price on Trip.com Check price on Expedia
Trip.com Guest Rating: 9.3/10
Location:
- 2130 Broadway, Manhattan, New York, New York State, 10023, United States
- 290m from 72nd Street Metro Station
- 380m from 79th Street Metro Station
- 3.9 km from Grand Central Terminal
- 4.4 km from New York Moynihan Train Hall at Penn Station
Hotel Highlights:
- Guestrooms featuring kitchenettes with refrigerators and stovetops
- Within 15-minute walk to Central Park
- 24-hour Fitness centre with gym
- Childcare service
- Limo/town car service and onsite self parking
What Guests Loved:
- Bus and subway access nearby and supermarket across the street
- Clean rooms with large, comfortable beds and with beautiful views
- Friendly service
- Quiet and convenient place amidst the hustle and bustle
- Fully equipped kitchen very convenient
Premium Economy: The Wallace
Check price on Trip.com Check price on Expedia
Trip.com Guest Rating: 9.5/10
Location:
- 242 W 76th St, Manhattan, New York, New York State, 10023, United States
- 320m from 79th Street Metro Station
- 440m from 72nd Street Metro Station
- 4 km from Grand Central Terminal
- 4.5 km from New York Moynihan Train Hall at Penn Station
Hotel Highlights:
- A 15-minute walk to Central Park
- Limo/town car service
- Onsite self parking and valet parking
- 24-hour fitness centre with gym
- Pets allowed (at a fee)
What Guests Loved:
- Excellent service and every amenity one could wish for
- Great front staff, spotlessly clean, quiet, and very comfortable
- Very stylish and clean hotel
- Very clean, comfortable rooms, helpful staff, convenient location
- As close to perfect as it gets
Business Class: The Mark New York
Check price on Trip.com Check price on Expedia
Trip.com Guest Rating: 9.3/10
Location:
- 25 E 77th St, Manhattan, New York, New York State, 10075, United States
- 350m from 77th Street Metro Station
- 1 km from 86th Street Metro Station
- 3.1 km from Grand Central Terminal
- 4.7 km from Harlem – 125th Street Train Station
Hotel Highlights:
- 24-hour Fitness centre with gym and massage room
- Private and valet parking and limo/car town service
- Beds with down comforters and premium bedding
- Currency exchange and multilingual in 9 languages
- Priority airport pick-up and drop-off
What Guests Loved:
- Welcoming atmosphere with family feel
- At excellent location and ideally situated for shopping
- Professional and friendly staff
- Fabulous breakfast, very comfortable rooms, good gym, great shopping nearby
- Superb accommodations, delicious food, set in the most luxurious place in NYC
First Class: The Lowell
Check price on Trip.com Check price on Expedia
Trip.com Guest Rating: 9.2/10
Location:
- 28 E 63rd St, Manhattan, New York, New York State, 10065, United States
- 340m from Lexington Avenue – 63rd Street Metro Station
- 1.7 km from Grand Central Terminal
- 2 km from Times Square
- 3.9 km from New York Moynihan Train Hall at Penn Station
Hotel Highlights:
- Perfect location in Manhattan’s Upper East Side
- Beds with down comforters and Frette Italian sheets
- Private and valet parking and limo/car town service
- Currency exchange, childcare service, and multilingual in 19 languages
- Gym, massage room, and 4 restaurants
What Guests Loved:
- An oasis of calm and elegance with old world luxury feel
- Top-notch accommodations, service, and hospitality
- One of the most romantic hotels in NYC with impeccable service
- Very comfortable and charming rooms with very comfortable beds
- Outstanding location close to all East Side museums and shopping
Planning the Next Stop on Your Itinerary
If your itinerary includes other destinations in North America, you may also want to explore our guides on Where to Stay in Chicago and Where to Stay in San Francisco or visit our Destinations page for more exciting destinations across the globe.
Affiliate Disclosure
Some links in this post are affiliate links. This means we may earn a small commission if you make a booking through these links, at no additional cost to you. This helps us continue providing honest, independent travel recommendations.
Our Editorial Methodology
Every hotel featured on HelpYouBook is selected using the same editorial methodology and quality standards. Our destination guides are designed to make comparing destinations easier by applying a consistent curation process, geographical areas, and budget tiers throughout the site.
To learn more about our curation process, hotel selection criteria, budget tiers, and editorial standards, please visit our About page.